Rashi demonstrates to you this concession was developed to avoid having a great boy crack what the law states. Due to lust, the new captor perform marry brand new captive the guy finds out trendy in place of consent. However, if he marries the lady, even after permission, he will grow to help you dislike the lady and you will she will sustain your an edgy guy. Rashi, such as the Bavli, will bring as the his facts the fresh new biblical proximity of your own pericopes about the the latest captive girl, the brand new hated girlfriend (Deut. 21: 15-17), in addition to rebellious boy. 41), Leqah Tov (p. 70), Yalkut Shimoni (p. 633), and you may Torah Tmimah (p. 279) together with make the standing you to definitely marrying an attentive woman was an enthusiastic hotel into evil choice: permissible but not preferred. Maimonides, when you look at the Hilkhot Melakhim 8: step one, states one to soldiers are permitted to eat restaurants that is normally taboo to Jews in the event the few other food is offered, hence implying one to captive women can be acceptance since no other girls are available. It may be seen most obviously that the post-biblical sages disapproved strongly away from a keen Israelite’s matrimony that have an attentive woman.
Due to the sages’ disapproval, one could merely speculate why you will find biblical permission so you’re able to get married a lady captive. Demonstrably, the newest sages thought that a captive lady exactly who turned into a partner is good issues. When your same feelings prevailed biblically, the text gets no for example sign.
Each other Deuteronomy 20: 1ff and 21: 10ff, for every single starting with “When you are onward so you can combat against their enemy,” of course target points where Israelites has reached combat, although effects for adversary women can be completely different during the for each and every case. That it improvement appears to be a purpose of theological toxic contamination, political handle, and you will geography.
Maimomides (Publication to the Mislead, guy
From inside the Deuteronomy seven: 1ff i realize off certain Canaanite countries that will be to get entirely shed while they could possibly get theologically pollute this new Israelites. So it admonition is frequent in Deuteronomy 20: 16,17. The newest regions whose annihilation is asked is regions who were expose inside Canaan when Joshua provided the Israelites.
Yet not, inside Deuteronomy 20: 10ff i read one to in the case of conflict having urban centers far away, places perhaps not of your particular nations listed above, an equivalent statutes of overall destruction do not incorporate. In the example of low-Canaanite urban centers, once they give up willingly, every populace feel subservient towards the Israelites. Whenever they do not surrender, the brand new guys about besieged city should be slain. The women, pupils, and you may possessions will be remaining because the damage because of the Israelites. Issue arises as to why the fresh new Bible allows the fresh new Israelites to have some of them lady because spouses.
We realize out-of Evaluator 21: fourteen you to from time to time there have been shortages of females. In this state, so that captive girls on the Israelite family members to help you procreate was an enthusiastic expedient size. Josephus in the conversation of captive girl (Antiquities IV: 258 ) says whenever a person takes a lady to help you enjoys pupils by this lady, he can be careful out-of the woman desires. The truth that he says that it in direct reference to the fresh new captive girl was high.
Their destruction not only suppress new theological toxic contamination of Israelites, it guarantees brand new Israelites’ political and you can military sovereignty of your own property
It may be construed we select a tension biblically ranging from driving a car out of theological pollution and also the unexpected need to replenish this new reproduction stock, whatever the cause. This may explain the inclusion of one’s rules enabling attentive spouses. It could check the aftereffect of Deuteronomy 20: sixteen,17 was to be sure political and you can theological continuation, due to the fact aftereffect of Deuteronomy 21: 10ff was to help biological continuation by enlarging and diversifying this new genetic pool from a non-harmful provider.